Teachers Beliefs about Classroom Management: Junior Teacher and Senior Teachers’ Beliefs about Classroom Management
1.0 Introduction
Classroom management is one of the main aspects the teachers must be expert in. Historically, teachers have ranked classroom as one of their major concerns (Rosas and West, 2008). Even over years of teaching experiences, the classroom management and the management of student are skills that must be explored and acquired throughout time to time (John, 1999). To be an effective teacher, the teacher should understand in more than one way the psychological and development levels of their students (Kizlik, 2012).
Therefore, in order to be an efficient teacher, the teacher must be good in teaching as well as in class management. Classroom is not just a place where the teaching and learning process take place but it is one examples of community where we can see many kind of environment exist. It is filled with people, materials, activities and tasks. The rules and routines in the classroom are determined by the teacher her/himself. The teacher becomes the authority who will assure that the classroom is well managed.
The reality is that it is a challenge for teacher to balance the classroom effective and efficiently due to the variety of students with varying diversity. Teacher may encounter with differences occurred among students such as racial and ethnic background. Sometimes there are factors that cannot be identified by the teacher immediately but it will be detected along the teaching and learning processes. Some of the factors are learning disabilities, religion, a child that lives with one and not both of their parents, or a child who lives with an extended family member or foster home, or a child that has parents of the same sex (Allen. S, 2009). Some other diversity differences are language, academic diversities, different needs, gender, disabilities, racial and ethnic differences (Ryan and Cooper, 2007).
Therefore, it is important for teacher to understand their roles in addressing diversity in the classroom and manage their students effectively. It is obvious then, that the teacher should embrace it and make positive of it. They must recognize and respect that students are different and these multiple differences are generally a good thing even though teacher will encounter with challenges in managing it.
In order to overcome the condition, teachers must provide a well managed classroom that can support the academic achievement for all students (Rosas and West, 2008). Teacher should find a suitable approach to be implemented in the classroom and at the same time they are ready to utilize and adapt it. Often, this will provide a conducive environment for teaching and learning for both teacher and students. However, the year of teaching experience has becomes a great concern for effective classroom management. Among junior teachers, the classroom management is considered as one of the aspect that they should major in their teaching skills. Even senior and experienced teachers have spent considerable time in discussing on major problem associated to classroom management (John, 1999).
Poor classroom management could lead to student misbehaviours which interfering the teaching-learning process. For beginner teacher, it might causes tremendous stress and the teacher becomes less motivated. If the condition is continuously occurs, it might lead to teachers exiting their profession. Even for senior teacher who has number of years experience in teaching, classroom management is still become their main obstacle in becoming an effective teacher. It is so challenging for in-service teachers in implementing and maintaining order while delivering and conveying order or instruction (Rosas and West, 2008). In order to promote academic success, teacher should be expert and master in classroom management whereby this will lead to establish learning environment.
1.1 Background of the Study
There has been growing concern about whether teachers’ belief among junior and senior teachers will lead to the different styles of teaching management in classroom. Study indicates that less experienced teachers differ from those who are more experience regarding their attitudes and beliefs toward classroom management (Rosas and West, 2008). While varying diversity exists among students, it is a challenge for educators to find a balance within their classroom that works effectively and efficiently with their personal management style (Stiller, 2010).
Teaching is a profession full with responsible which requires teachers to be responsive to new demands and changing needs for both experts and beginner teacher (Allen, 2010). There is a related issue that has received less attention but has been concerned among junior or senior teachers which is classroom management. Over a few decades, research has consistently indicates that new teachers are feel unprepared when comes to classroom management skills (Duck, 2007). New teachers are also said to be left behind and functioning inefficient regarding managing administration tasks, curriculum and behaviour problem (Allen and Blackston, 2003). A study also indicates that new teacher develop perceptions of classroom management from their own experience as a students and during teacher preparing courses and these perceptions persist well during the early year of teaching at school (Fajet, Bello,Leftwich, Mesler and Shaver, 2005). Thus, beginner teachers find that the poor classroom management has been a significant barrier to their career development and professional success (Fideler and Haskelhorn, 1999).
However, on the other hand, experienced teachers are believed to be more capable in prioritize tasks and blending the years of service with classroom management and teaching skills (Hagger and McIntyre, 2000). Thus, it is important to understand more on the differences of beliefs on classroom management between junior and senior teachers.
In addition, it is important for teachers to determine the suitable models or strategies to align them with the pressing needs of students (Stiller, 2010). Furthermore, teacher should identify which strategies might work well and blend with the teaching strategies used. This also means that there is a specific requirement to understand how these strategies can promote critical thinking in the students (Bonner, 2012).
1.2 Problem Statement
In reality, a carrier as a teacher is full with heavy-duty responsible. It is said that teacher is a job with no name. Teacher can be anybody and everything in student’s world. It is obvious then teacher being a person that carry a responsible to change and educate society. Therefore, with the overwhelming responsibilities on their shoulders, classroom management and effective teaching are always at the frontline of teaching.
It is highly crucial that the teacher’s belief towards the classroom management in classroom is taken into priority. With many kind of diversity level occurred among students, the focus on identify and recognizes the learning models or learning strategies is needed in order to meet with the student needs. However, the junior and senior teacher might have different beliefs toward the learning strategies to be implemented in the classroom.
Nevertheless, teachers are required to identify the most suitable strategies that can work well and blend with the student. Teacher may have many approaches in their teaching strategies but to make the teaching effectively, teachers can narrow down their method of classroom management based on their philosophy of education and the students need.
Therefore, another problem that can be identified in this research is the belief of junior teacher and senior teachers upon the classroom management whereby it can promote the critical thinking in the teaching and learning process. This is due to the correct strategies and model used and utilized by teachers can lead to succeed in student learning process.
1.3 Research Objective
The purpose of conducting this research is to find out the teachers’ beliefs toward classroom management. The specific objectives of this study are:
1) To investigate teachers’ beliefs on classroom management among junior teacher.
2) To investigate teachers’ beliefs on classroom management among senior teacher.
3) To analyse the differences of beliefs on classroom management between junior and senior teachers.
1.4 Research Question
This study attempts to answer the following research questions. The questions are:
1) What are the teachers’ beliefs on classroom management among junior teacher?
2) What are the teachers’ beliefs on classroom management among senior teacher?
3) What are the differences of beliefs between junior and senior teacher on classroom management approaches?
1.5 Significance of the Study
Primarily, this study has significance for teachers to provide a classroom that support academic achievement for all students. The data collected from this study might be useful in understanding more on how teachers’ beliefs on classroom management could help teachers to cater the classroom and to organize instruction effectively. As teacher encounter with many kinds of diverse group, students needed to be taught in vary approaches. Hence, the finding in this study will provide insights and understanding on whether the junior teachers and senior teachers have same beliefs on classroom management.
In addition, the study could become guidance for teachers on how to adapt to classroom management techniques which could be gained through years of teaching experience. By utilize and blend the methods which can link positive effects towards the classroom management, teacher will understand more how to create an environment that is conducive to teaching-learning processes and at the same time the student will feels valued and respected.
The outcomes of the study could also provide information for future research. The present study shows that experienced teachers are more likely in control with their classroom than beginning teacher while interacting with students.
1.6 Limitation of Study
The main limitation for this research is the number of sample. The sample which is the respondants in this study were 30 teachers from SMK Lembah Subang, Petaling Jaya. The number of sample is considered small. Thus it will affect the results obtained from the respondants whereby it does not show the exact “teachers beliefs” regarding classroom management.
In addition, this was a quantitative study. It used a survey in form of closed ended questions to collect data from the respondents. This type of data collected provided a limited nature of responses given by the respondents. Thus, the results obtained do not addressed the actual teachers’ beliefs on classroom management. If so, the data collected may have skewed the results.
1.7 Operational definition
This section elaborates on the operational definition of classroom management, importance, teacher’s understanding and student diversity.
1.7.1 Teachers’ Belief
Teachers’ belief can be referred as ideas, doctrines, tenets, etc. that are accepted by teachers as true on grounds which are not immediately susceptible to rigorous proof (Glossary of Education, 2013).
1.7.2 Classroom Management
Classroom management is the term educators used to describe methods of preventing misbehaviour and dealing with it (Kelly, 2010). In other words, it is the action or techniques taken by teachers in order to maintain control in the classroom. Classroom management also can be described as efforts taken in monitoring the activities in the classroom including learning, social interaction and students behaviour (Martin, Yin and Baldwin, 1998). According to Randi McCreary (2005), “classroom management is defined as the methods and strategies uses to maintain a classroom environment that is conducive to student success and learning”.
1.7.3 Junior Teacher
In this study, junior teacher is refer to the certified teachers that entered their first teaching position (Glossary of Education, 2013)
1.7.4 Senior Teacher
A senior teacher can be described as teachers with many years of experience in teaching (Glossary of Education, 2013).
References
Allen, K.P. (2010). Classroom Management, Bullying and Teacher Practice. The Professional Educator. 34(1), pp. 1
Allen, S. (2009). Diversity in the classroom. Retrieved April 22, 2013 from http://voices.yahoo.com/diversity-classroom-3860824.html
Allen, S.J., Blackston, A.R. (2003) Training preservice teachers in collaborative problem solving: An investigation of the impact of teacher and student behaviour change in real-world setting. School Psychology Quartely, 18(1), pp.22-51
Bonner, J.A. (2012). Student Diversity and Classroom Management. Grand Canyon University
Duck, L. (2007). Using sounder foundation to helps avoid the “why new teacher cry” phenomenon. The cleasing house, 81(1), pp. 29-36.
Fajet, W., Bello, M., Leftwitch, S.A., Mesler, J.L., and Shaner, A.N. (2005). Preservice teachers’ perception in beginning education classes. Teaching & Teachers Education, 21.pp. 717-727
Hagger, H. & McIntyre, D. (2000). What can research tell us about teacher education? Oxford Review of Education, 26(3-4), pp. 483-495.
Kelly. M. (2012). Retrieved April 21, 2013 from http://712educators.about.com/od/classroomhelpers/g/Definition-Of-Classroom-Management.htm
Kizlik. B.(2012). Classroom Management, Management of Student Conduct, Effective Praise Guideline, and a Few Things to Know About ESOL Thrown in for Good Measure. Florida.
Martin, N.K., Yin, Z. & Baldwin, B (1998). Classroom management training, class size and graduate study: Do these variables impact teachers’ beliefs regarding classroom management style? Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association , San Diego, CA.
Ryan and Cooper.2007.Those Who Can, Teach11 Edition.Ch.3”Who Are Today’s Students in A Diverse Society?” (p.51-85). Houghton Mifflin Company. Boston, MA
Rosas, C. & West, M. (2008). Teachers Beliefs about Classroom Management: Per-service and Inservice Teachers’ Belief about Classroom Management. IJAES. 5(1), pp. 54-61
Stiller, N. (2010). The Effects Student Diversity Has on Classroom Management. Retrieved April 21 2013 from http://voices.yahoo.com/the-effects-student-diversity-has-classroom-management-7306138.html
Randi, M. (2005). Classroom Management Definition. Retrieved April 15, 2013 from http://www.ehow.com/about_5438989_classroom-management-definition.html#ixzz2PkZkep6F
http://www.education.com/definition/teachers-beliefs/